Before jumping in the details of the Inspection and Audits, let me explain PDCA Cycle;
PDCA by Mindtools
Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle to differentiate between audits and inspections. At a high level, inspections are a “do” and audits are a “check”.
Now the PMBOK 6 Definitions;
An audit is a structured, independent process used to determine if project activities comply with organizational and project policies, processes, and procedures
Inspection includes activities such as measuring, examining, and validating to determine whether work and deliverables meet requirements and product acceptance criteria
Inspection
The term ‘Inspection’ refers to a vital element of the project management process that involves in execution and effective completion of a project. The entire project team put in efforts to thoroughly review the completeness of the project including products, services, and activities and figure out whether the project meets the defined objectives. In certain cases, an independent third party conducts an inspection of final deliverables that allows a mediator to measure the effectiveness from a neutral perspective.
A project management audit is scrutiny designed to define the current status of work performed on a particular schedule considering the major components such as schedule and budget limitations. It refers to the independent and structured evaluation of the state of affairs directed by a proficient examiner. It provides insights into the work required in meeting project objectives along with highlighting mistakes that can lead to project failure and trigger timely corrective action. These audits are often associated with the general supervision of project management along with financial audits. A set of guidelines are formulated in preparing, performing, and reporting an audit. It involves:
Strategic project management tools for aligning and monitoring diverse features of a project
Identify defined phases and processes through a project’s lifecycle
Allocation of responsibilities that every project phase complies with critical project objectives
Why both are important
Inspections and audits are important tools involved in the procurement process that is implied in the execution of the project. One important benefit is that they aim to verify the deliverables or processes that comply with the needs of the project owner. Additionally, they serve as an important risk analysis in which systemic examination is performed to determine the degree of the situation and provide the execution of efficient management policies.
Comparison
The goal of an audit is usually to assess overall compliance with one or more regulations, internal policies, or other compliance drivers.
Audits are to improve the process or product. therefore it is the part of Manage Quality in Project Quality Management
Inspections can be thought of as compliance tasks with checklists.
Inspections to identify failures and it is part of Control Quality of Project Quality Management
Mudassir Iqbal has extensive experience of 20 years in the field of Project Management and digital transformation and has been actively providing training in various courses of PMP, CBAP, and others both domestically and internationally. His areas of experience include project management, program management, business intelligence, and information warehousing. He is a certified project manager whose profound experience enables him to simultaneously manage high-risk and high-performing projects.Mudassir has taught project management certification courses for the past ten years at multiple levels. In addition to project management preparation course, he has also provided training in other courses for business analysis agile certification programs. The inspiration for offering the online training course in the field of project management came from his own experience. Understanding the fact that it’s both time and energy-consuming to read several books and blogs, he came up with the idea of establishing an online training platform. The platform offers users with comprehensive training sessions to get them well-prepared for their PMP examination and save their precious time.
